Loaner Cars: Are Cameras Watching You?

Loaner cars, or cars provided by dealerships to customers for free, sometimes have cameras installed in them. These cameras are often used to monitor and record vehicle drop-off and delivery spots to protect the dealership from false claims of vehicle damage. Additionally, these cameras can help prevent vehicle theft and monitor employee activity. While some dealerships may choose to install cameras in their loaner cars, it is not a standard practice across the industry, and the presence of cameras may vary depending on the dealership's policies and preferences.

Loaner car cameras can help prevent vehicle theft

Car theft is a common occurrence, with thieves targeting vehicles left idling, those with keys or fobs left inside, and older models without anti-theft technology. As such, loaner car companies are increasingly turning to cameras as a way to deter and prevent theft of their vehicles.

Deterring theft

Cameras installed in loaner cars can act as a visual deterrent, making potential thieves think twice before targeting the vehicle. This is especially true if the cameras are clearly visible and accompanied by a sign or sticker indicating that the car is under surveillance.

Monitoring and tracking

Loaner car cameras can also be used to monitor the vehicle in real time, allowing the company to track its location and receive alerts if the car strays outside a designated area. This can help prevent theft by allowing the company to quickly locate and recover the vehicle if it is moved without authorization.

Evidence collection

In the event that a loaner car is stolen, cameras can provide valuable evidence to aid in the investigation and help authorities identify and apprehend the thieves. This can lead to faster recovery of the vehicle and increase the chances of holding the perpetrators accountable.

Customer satisfaction

In addition to preventing theft, cameras can also improve customer satisfaction. For example, if a customer disputes the existence of damage to the vehicle upon return, the company can review the camera footage to determine whether the damage was pre-existing or occurred during the rental period. This can help resolve disputes amicably and maintain a positive relationship with the customer.

Privacy concerns

While cameras in loaner cars can provide several benefits, it is important to consider potential privacy concerns. Some people may feel uncomfortable with the idea of being recorded while driving, so it is crucial for loaner car companies to be transparent about the presence of cameras and obtain the customer's consent. Additionally, measures should be taken to ensure the security and privacy of any data collected, including footage and vehicle location information.

In conclusion, loaner car cameras can be an effective tool for preventing vehicle theft and protecting the interests of both the company and its customers. However, it is important for loaner car companies to balance the benefits of surveillance with the privacy expectations of their customers.

They can be used to monitor and record vehicle drop-off and delivery

Cameras in loaner cars can be used to monitor and record vehicle drop-off and delivery spots throughout the dealership. This can be extremely useful in the case of false vehicle-damage reports.

For example, Jeff Sterry, service manager at BMW of Catonsville in Baltimore, noticed that many customers were reporting damage to their cars brought in for service. He decided to install the Eyewitness Surveillance Service Lane System, an internal hidden camera system that monitors and records vehicle drop-off and delivery spots and other areas throughout the dealership's interior. Sterry found that about 90% of the time, the damage was already there when the customer brought the car in for service.

This system has helped the dealership save tens of thousands of dollars in false vehicle-damage reports, as well as helped catch bad employees and prevent potential vehicle thefts. It has also improved customer satisfaction, as Sterry can show customers that his shop did not damage their cars.

In addition to monitoring vehicle drop-off and delivery, the cameras can also be used to monitor new and used car deliveries. This can help protect the dealership from customers who try to return a car a few days later, claiming that it was damaged. With the cameras, Sterry can show that there was no damage when the customer left the dealership.

They can help dealerships save money on false damage claims

Dealerships can save a lot of money by installing cameras in their loaner cars. Cameras can monitor and record vehicle drop-off and delivery spots throughout the dealership. This helps dealerships save money on false damage claims.

For example, Service Manager Jeff Sterry of BMW of Catonsville in Baltimore noticed that his shop was spending thousands of dollars per month on repairs for damages that customers claimed occurred during service. However, after installing cameras, Sterry found that about 90% of the time, the damage was already present when the car was brought in for service. This resulted in savings of $20,000 to $30,000 over two years for BMW of Catonsville.

In addition to saving money on false damage claims, dealerships can also use cameras to protect their loaner cars from theft and monitor employee behaviour. For instance, Sterry mentioned that BMW of Catonsville had used the cameras to catch employees engaging in inappropriate behaviour and to thwart a possible vehicle theft.

While some may argue that cameras in loaner cars invade privacy, it is important to note that they are primarily used as a defensive tool to protect the dealership's assets and improve customer satisfaction. Sterry mentioned that showing customers video evidence of their car's condition upon drop-off helped retain customers and improve their satisfaction.

Furthermore, dealerships can also save money by offering loaner cars to customers. This strategy has led to increased sales as customers can experience new technology, interior refinements, and improved fuel economy. Dealerships may also receive incentives from automakers to provide loaner cars, making it a cost-effective strategy. Overall, the use of cameras and loaner cars can help dealerships save money and improve their operations.

They can be used to monitor employee behaviour

In-car surveillance systems can be used to monitor employee behaviour. This can be done using GPS tracking devices, which are often installed under the bonnet, in the dashboard, or plugged directly into the onboard diagnostics port. These devices use the Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS) to track location, speed, movement, stopping times, and vehicle diagnostics. The data is then transmitted wirelessly or via a cellular network to provide real-time updates and alerts.

The use of vehicle trackers can help employers boost efficiency and productivity by monitoring driver location and managing their fleet. It can also help to optimise routes, improve customer service, and minimise safety risks, fuel consumption, and vehicle depreciation caused by speeding or other unsafe driving patterns.

In the context of a disciplinary hearing, the data collected from vehicle trackers can be used as evidence of employee misconduct. For example, if GPS data reveals excessive vehicle speeds, this can be used to support an allegation of misconduct. However, it is important to note that tracking employees without their knowledge or consent is illegal in the UK and other countries. Employees have a right to privacy, and tracking should be limited to work hours and work-related activities.

In one example, a dealership in Baltimore installed an internal hidden camera system that monitored vehicle drop-off and delivery spots. This system helped to catch employees who were not doing what they were supposed to do, and the dealership subsequently fired two employees based on the footage.

They can be used to monitor speeding and prevent drivers from crossing state lines

Loaner cars are vehicles lent to customers by car dealerships while their cars are being serviced or repaired. While these cars are usually owned by the dealership, some dealerships may partner with rental car companies to provide loaner cars to their customers.

In either case, loaner cars may be equipped with cameras, just like any other rental car. These cameras are typically part of the vehicle's dashboard navigation system and are often linked to an automated ticketing system. While the cameras in loaner cars are usually inactive, they can be used to monitor speeding and prevent drivers from crossing state lines.

In the United States, rental car companies have been known to fine customers for violating the terms of their contracts, including speeding and crossing state lines. For example, a customer of Acme Rent-a-Car was fined $450 ($150 per incident) for exceeding posted speed limits, even without receiving any traffic citations. Similarly, a Payless customer was charged an additional $3,405.05 for driving across state lines, as their contract prohibited leaving the state.

To avoid fines, it is important for drivers to carefully review the rental agreement and be mindful of any restrictions on speeding or crossing state lines. While the use of tracking devices has become less prevalent due to customer backlash and negative media attention, it is still a common practice among small, independent rental car companies. These companies often cite concerns about vehicle theft and abuse as reasons for implementing tracking measures.

It is worth noting that the use of tracking devices and cameras in rental cars can vary depending on the company, location, and local laws. While some states and provinces, such as Alberta, operate under "owner liability," where the registered owner of the vehicle is responsible for paying fines, other states may require the actual driver to be identified for criminal violations.

Frequently asked questions