Traffic Cameras In Monroe County, Fl: What Happened?

Traffic cameras have been a contentious issue in Monroe County, Florida. While some local officials support their implementation for safety reasons, others argue that the lack of public feedback indicates opposition. The cameras were initially installed in Monroe in 2007, but a citizen-led ballot initiative opposing them emerged in 2011. The council majority rejected putting the initiative on the ballot, and the cameras remained active until December 2013, when they were deactivated due to a combination of an expired contract and their unpopularity. As of June 2024, the city council was discussing the potential addition of traffic enforcement cameras, but no decision had been made, and the matter may be put to an advisory vote. Live traffic cameras are currently available on certain roads in Monroe County, such as U.S. One, and can be accessed through the Florida 511 website or mobile app.

Traffic cameras were removed in 2013 due to unpopularity

Traffic cameras were removed from Monroe County, Florida, in 2013 due to their unpopularity. The cameras were deactivated in December 2013, with the city's contract with the camera company expiring after five years. The decision to remove the cameras was likely influenced by the lack of public support, as the cameras had faced opposition since their activation in June 2011.

The cameras were initially installed to enforce traffic laws, including speed limits and red-light running. However, the public reception was largely negative, with a citizen-led ballot initiative opposing the cameras emerging soon after their activation. Despite the Monroe City Council's majority rejecting this initiative, the opposition persisted.

The cameras were located on power poles at several locations, including MM90.4, MM86.2, MM80, MM77, and MM74. These cameras provided live traffic feeds, allowing residents to monitor traffic conditions and incidents. While some may have found this information useful, it was not enough to outweigh the unpopularity of the cameras.

The removal of the cameras in 2013 was a response to the public sentiment and likely a recognition that the benefits of the cameras did not outweigh the costs and logistical challenges associated with their operation. The city has continued to explore alternatives to address traffic safety concerns, such as potential speed zone cameras in school zones, which have gained stronger community support.

The discussion around traffic cameras in Monroe County, Florida, highlights the complexities of implementing technology for enforcement. While safety concerns are paramount, the acceptance and support of the community are crucial for the successful integration of such measures.

The Monroe City Council considered adding traffic cameras in June 2024

In June 2024, the Monroe City Council considered adding traffic cameras to improve road safety and address traffic violations. The council discussed the potential of installing traffic enforcement cameras in school speed zones and at red lights. While some council members supported the idea, citing frequent complaints about speeding, others noted a lack of public feedback in favor of the proposal. The council identified several areas where cameras could enhance enforcement, such as Main Street, 179th Street, and U.S. 2.

The discussion highlighted the mixed reactions among residents, with some expressing concerns about the cost and logistical aspects of enforcement. It was suggested that restricting camera use to school zones could be a more acceptable approach due to stronger community support for addressing speeding in these areas. The council planned to continue discussions and make a decision by July 30 if an advisory vote were to be included on the November ballot.

Monroe had previously established a contract with a camera company in 2007, and the cameras were activated in June 2011. However, due to unpopularity and the expiration of the contract in December 2013, the red-light cameras were deactivated. The council's current considerations aim to address road safety and traffic violations effectively while taking into account the diverse opinions of the community.

Traffic cameras are already in use in Monroe County, Florida, with cameras monitoring traffic on some power poles through the Keys. These cameras provide real-time traffic updates and are accessible through the Florida 511 Mobile App and the Monroe County Sheriff's Office App. Additionally, the Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) provides traffic information and alerts for South Florida, including Monroe County.

The council identified several areas where cameras could aid enforcement

The addition of traffic enforcement cameras in these locations would help to monitor and regulate traffic flow, ensuring that speed limits are adhered to and reducing the risk of accidents. The cameras would provide a deterrent for speeding and red-light running, improving road safety for all users.

In particular, the presence of cameras in school speed zones has been suggested as a "no-brainer" by Councilmember Jacob Walker. School zones are areas where children are present, and ensuring drivers adhere to the speed limit is crucial for their safety. The cameras would act as a visual reminder for drivers to slow down and be more cautious in these areas.

Furthermore, the use of cameras could potentially extend beyond just speed and red-light enforcement. They could also be utilised for congestion monitoring and incident detection, providing real-time data to help manage traffic flow and respond to accidents or road closures promptly.

By leveraging the capabilities of traffic cameras, the council can enhance road safety, improve traffic management, and address specific concerns raised by residents.

Councilmembers noted a lack of public support for traffic cameras

During a City Council meeting in Monroe, Snohomish County, councilmembers discussed the potential addition of traffic enforcement cameras in school speed zones and for red light enforcement. While some councilmembers expressed support for the idea, citing frequent complaints about speeding and safety concerns, others noted a lack of public support for traffic cameras. Councilmembers Kevin Hanford and Kirk Scarboro mentioned that they had not received any public comments or emails from citizens expressing interest or support for red-light traffic cameras. Hanford and Scarboro interpreted this silence as opposition to the proposal.

The discussion highlighted the differing opinions among councilmembers and the community. Councilmember Kyle Fisher, who supported the use of cameras, mentioned that the council had been receiving frequent complaints about speeding. Similarly, Councilmember Tami Beaumont expressed her support, stating that there were some unsafe streets in the city. Councilmember Jacob Walker specifically advocated for speed zone cameras in school zones, calling it a "no-brainer."

On the other hand, Hanford and Scarboro's observations about the lack of public support indicated that the proposal might not be well-received by the community. Hanford suggested putting the issue to an advisory vote, which could include a detailed list of reasons for implementing the traffic cameras. Walker also showed interest in continuing discussions about the cost and logistics of enforcement, suggesting that camera use be restricted to school zones due to stronger community support in that specific area.

The council identified several areas where cameras could aid enforcement, including Main Street, 179th Street, U.S. 2, Powell Street, and Sams Street. However, the decision-making process was still ongoing, and the city had not committed to the traffic camera proposal at the time of the meeting. The council intended to continue discussions and make a decision by July 30 if an advisory vote were to be included on the November ballot.

Traffic cameras are accessible via the Monroe County Sheriff's Office App

Traffic cameras are accessible via the Monroe County Sheriffs Office App. This app can be downloaded to your smartphone from the app store. The app provides up-to-date traffic reports and information about accidents and road closures.

In addition to the Monroe County Sheriff's Office App, there are several other resources for monitoring traffic in Monroe County, Florida. The Florida 511 website and mobile app offer real-time traffic conditions, incident information, and turn-by-turn directions for the state of Florida. The Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) also provides traffic camera footage through its partner website, SunGuide.Info.

The use of traffic enforcement cameras in Monroe County has been a topic of discussion among the City Council. In June 2024, the council discussed the potential of adding traffic cameras in school speed zones and for red-light enforcement. While some council members supported the idea, citing safety concerns and complaints about speeding, others noted a lack of public interest in implementing traffic cameras. The council planned to continue discussions and consider putting the issue to an advisory vote in the upcoming general election.

Previously, Monroe had established a contract with a camera company in 2007, and the cameras were activated in June 2011. However, in December 2013, the red-light cameras were deactivated due to the expiration of the contract and their unpopularity among residents. The decision to deactivate the cameras was made by the city, and a citizen-led ballot initiative opposing the cameras was rejected by the City Council majority at the time.

Frequently asked questions