Cutting Off Ankle Monitors: Criminal Action Or Personal Freedom?

Ankle monitors are often used as an alternative to pre-trial detention or as a condition of probation. They are usually worn by people who are considered a danger to the community or a flight risk. The monitors are designed to ensure that the wearer stays within the boundaries set by the court and can be used to track the wearer's movement and location. While it is possible to cut off an ankle monitor, it is a crime to do so and can result in additional penalties, including jail time. In addition to cutting off their ankle monitors, some people have also been known to let the batteries on their devices die, which is also considered a violation of the terms of their release.

It can be considered a form of escape or evasion

Ankle monitors are typically used as an alternative to pre-trial detention or as a condition of probation. They are often used to ensure that the wearer stays within a certain radius of their home, regularly checks in with their probation officer, and adheres to a curfew. By cutting off an ankle monitor, a person can escape these restrictions and evade the authorities.

In Texas, for example, cutting off an ankle monitor was previously only considered an administrative violation. However, a new law was passed in May 2023, making it a crime to cut off one's ankle monitor. This change was prompted by several incidents where suspects committed crimes or disappeared after cutting off their ankle monitors.

The act of cutting off an ankle monitor can be seen as a form of escape or evasion as it allows individuals to break free from the constraints imposed by the device. It provides them with the opportunity to move beyond the designated areas, avoid check-ins, and potentially flee from the authorities. This action can be particularly appealing to those who feel that the restrictions are too harsh or unfair. For instance, in one case, a person shared their experience of struggling with the limitations imposed by the monitor, stating that it interfered with their ability to work and attend school.

Additionally, the financial burden associated with ankle monitors can also drive people to cut them off. In some jurisdictions, the fees for wearing these devices can be substantial, ranging from $3 to $35 per day, on top of initial setup charges. This can be a significant challenge for individuals and their families, especially if they are already dealing with financial difficulties.

Cutting off an ankle monitor can provide a sense of freedom and relief from the constraints and stressors associated with the device. However, it is important to note that doing so is illegal in many places and can result in serious consequences, including arrest and additional charges.

It may result in further charges

Ankle monitors are typically used as an alternative to pre-trial detention or as a condition of probation. They are often used for people who are considered a danger to the community or a flight risk. The purpose of an ankle monitor is to ensure that the wearer stays within the boundaries set by the court and does not get into more trouble. By cutting off an ankle monitor, an individual is violating the terms of their release and may face additional penalties, including jail time.

In the state of Texas, cutting off an ankle monitor was previously only considered an administrative violation. However, as of September 1, 2023, a new law went into effect that makes it a crime to cut off an ankle monitor. This change was prompted by several incidents where suspects committed violent crimes after cutting off their ankle monitors, including the 2022 shooting at Methodist Hospital Dallas. Under the new law, breaking an ankle monitor is treated similarly to breaking out of jail, and offenders will be sent back to jail to serve the rest of their sentence, in addition to facing felony charges.

The consequences of cutting off an ankle monitor can vary depending on the jurisdiction and the individual's criminal history. In some cases, it may result in a formal violation and potential new charges. For example, in the case of a juvenile who cuts off their ankle monitor, they may be held on a "juvenile detainer" until the courts can sort out the situation. Additionally, there may be financial consequences, as the individual may be responsible for the cost of the monitor and any associated fees.

It is important to note that the specific consequences of cutting off an ankle monitor may differ depending on the legal system and the circumstances of the case. While it may not always lead to new criminal charges, it is still a serious violation that can have significant repercussions. Consulting with a legal professional who is knowledgeable about the laws in one's jurisdiction is essential to understanding the potential consequences and exploring possible defence strategies.

It can be costly

In Texas, cutting off your ankle monitor is a crime. As of September 1, 2023, it is a felony and can result in jail time and a fine.

In other states, the consequences of cutting off your ankle monitor vary. In some cases, it may be considered a violation of the terms of your release or probation, which could result in additional penalties, including jail time. Additionally, you may be required to pay for the cost of the monitor, which can range from $1,740 to $2,000 per unit, plus daily GPS fees. These costs can quickly add up, especially if you are on the monitor for an extended period.

For example, in Maricopa County, Arizona, Matthew Brown has been on an ankle monitor for three years pending trial. He worries about the eventual cost of the monitor, which could be $10 a day, amounting to $10,000 over three years. Brown also mentions that water damage from his job as a boat captain has ruined about a dozen monitors, which could result in additional fees.

The financial burden of ankle monitors can be significant, especially for those who are already struggling financially or trying to reintegrate into society after incarceration. In Detroit, for instance, the daily fees for wearing an ankle monitor range from $3 to $35, with initial setup charges of $100 to $200. These costs can be burdensome for individuals and families, especially when coupled with other expenses related to incarceration and reentry.

Therefore, it is essential to consider the potential costs and consequences before tampering with or cutting off an ankle monitor. While it may seem like a way to escape monitoring or avoid violating the terms of your release, it can ultimately lead to more severe legal and financial repercussions.

It could be due to malfunction or discomfort

Ankle monitors are usually strapped to the ankle with a tamper-proof band. However, in some cases, people under house arrest may cut off their ankle monitors. While this may be a deliberate attempt to escape, it could also be due to malfunction or discomfort.

Ankle monitors are often uncomfortable to wear, and if not done correctly, can lead to an unbearable and sometimes painful experience. For instance, the device may be too tight or too loose, causing chafing and skin irritation. In such cases, individuals may be tempted to adjust or remove the monitor to alleviate the discomfort.

Additionally, malfunction of the device can also lead to individuals tampering with their ankle monitors. For example, if the battery dies or the device fails to function properly, individuals may attempt to remove or adjust the monitor in an effort to fix the issue.

It is important to note that cutting off an ankle monitor, regardless of the reason, can have legal consequences. If you are experiencing discomfort or malfunction with your ankle monitor, it is advisable to seek help from the appropriate authorities or legal professionals instead of taking matters into your own hands.

It may be a result of mental health issues

Cutting off an ankle monitor is a crime and can result in re-arrest and additional charges. Ankle monitors are used as a condition of bail or parole, or as an alternative to pre-trial detention. They are usually reserved for people awaiting trial who are considered a danger to the community or a flight risk.

Mental illness and crime are linked, with some types of severe mental illness increasing the risk of perpetrating a violent crime. While it is important to note that having a severe mental health problem does not make a person violent, and that people with conditions like schizophrenia are more likely to be victims of violence, mental illness can be a significant factor in some crimes. Untreated severe mental illness is particularly relevant in cases of homicide and mass murders of strangers.

Research has shown that early intervention is key to helping those with mental illness. However, many mental health hospitals have seen their capacity decrease over the years, while prison populations have increased, with mentally ill prisoners comprising a large fraction of the prison population. This has resulted in a lack of access to mental health treatment, which could have long-term benefits for individuals and society.

Adverse childhood experiences, such as growing up amidst violence, poverty, abuse, chronic stress, or chronic unpredictability, can also have permanent effects on the brains and bodies of children, increasing the risk of mental health issues such as depression, anxiety, and substance abuse.

Therefore, it is possible that individuals who cut off their ankle monitors may be struggling with mental health issues, either as a result of untreated mental illness or adverse childhood experiences.

Frequently asked questions