Car Cameras In Michigan: Are They Legal?

Dashcams and security cameras are legal in Michigan, but there are some important considerations and restrictions. Dashcams cannot be mounted on windshields as they obstruct the driver's view, but they can be placed on dashboards or behind the rearview mirror. Michigan is a two-party consent state, so recording audio conversations with dashcams requires the consent of all involved parties.

Michigan law prohibits video recording individuals without their knowledge or consent in areas where they have a reasonable expectation of privacy, such as bathrooms, bedrooms, and changing rooms.

While there is currently no law allowing red light cameras in Michigan, legislation to ban them has not yet passed the House. Traffic cameras in construction zones, on the other hand, are gaining traction and may soon be implemented.

Dash cams are legal in Michigan, but they cannot be mounted on windshields

Dash cams are legal in Michigan, but there are some important considerations to keep in mind. Firstly, according to Michigan law, dash cams cannot be mounted on windshields as they can obstruct the driver's view of the road. This restriction is lifted for buses, truck tractors, or trucks weighing more than 10,000 pounds or transporting hazardous waste.

While you can legally record video in public spaces without consent, Michigan law prohibits video recording of individuals without their knowledge or consent in areas where they have a reasonable expectation of privacy, such as bathrooms, bedrooms, and changing rooms. Additionally, Michigan is a two-party consent state, meaning that recording audio conversations requires the consent of all involved parties. Failure to obtain consent can result in severe penalties, including fines and imprisonment.

It is worth noting that the Michigan State Police have been utilizing in-car video systems since the mid-1990s, and these systems are admissible in court as evidence.

When installing and using dash cams in Michigan, it is crucial to be aware of the legal restrictions regarding placement and audio recording to avoid any potential violations of privacy and consent laws.

Michigan does not have red light cameras

Red light cameras are automated tools used by law enforcement to monitor and enforce traffic laws. They capture images of vehicles that run red lights. However, Michigan residents and visitors can still get a ticket for running a red light. If a police officer observes a driver running a red light, they can issue a ticket.

Traffic cameras, which are often confused with red light cameras, are used to monitor traffic flow and road conditions. They do not issue tickets and are typically located on top of the traffic light. Michigan does have traffic cameras, which are located in major cities such as Detroit, Grand Rapids, Ann Arbor, and Lansing.

Michigan State Police work sites began to receive in-car video systems in the mid-1990s through a grant from the Michigan Office of Highway Safety Planning. These in-car cameras are used to establish audio and video recordings that can be admitted in court as evidence to augment officer investigations.

Michigan State Police use in-car video systems

The Michigan State Police (MSP) is a full-service law enforcement agency with approximately 3,000 employees. The MSP uses in-car video systems to establish audio and video recordings that can be used as evidence in court to support officer investigations.

In the mid-1990s, some Michigan State Police work sites began to receive in-car video systems through a grant from the Michigan Office of Highway Safety Planning. The Michigan State Police secured a contract with Digital Ally, Inc. for the purchase of in-car video systems, which are also made available to local government units.

The MSP conducts annual tests of police and special services vehicles, including testing for top speed, acceleration, braking, ergonomics, and communications. These tests are carried out at the Grattan Raceway in Grattan Township, Michigan, to simulate emergency response driving conditions. The results of these tests are published and provide valuable data for over 30,000 law enforcement departments in the country.

The MSP is responsible for a range of duties, including criminal investigations, traffic enforcement, community outreach, and providing support to other law enforcement agencies. They have various specialized teams, such as the Aviation Unit, Bomb Squad, and Marine Services Team, and they coordinate state-level homeland security initiatives. The MSP also operates a Training Academy that offers learning opportunities and training programs for its employees and the broader criminal justice community.

Michigan is a two-party consent state—all parties must consent to audio recordings

Michigan's laws on recording conversations are quite complex. While it is often labelled as a one-party consent state, this is not entirely accurate. Michigan's eavesdropping statute states that a person is guilty of a felony if they:

> Willfully use a device to eavesdrop on a conversation without the consent of all parties involved.

This makes it seem like Michigan is an all-party consent state. However, the Michigan Court of Appeals has interpreted the statute to include an exception for participants of the conversation. This is because the term "eavesdrop" was deemed to only pertain to the private conversations of other people.

Therefore, a participant in a private conversation can record without the consent of the other participants. However, this exception does not apply to recording phone calls or electronic communications. For these types of communications, all parties must consent to the recording.

It is important to note that Michigan's wiretapping law also prohibits the use of devices to observe or record sound or video of a person in a private place without their consent. A private place is defined as an area where a person is expected to be safe from intrusion or surveillance without their consent.

Additionally, Michigan law permits the video and audio recording of state court hearings with the permission of the presiding judge. Federal courts in Michigan, on the other hand, do not allow recording devices and cameras in the courtroom.

Michigan law prohibits video recording individuals without their consent in areas where they have a reasonable expectation of privacy

Michigan's recording laws are some of the most stringent in the country, with the state prohibiting the recording and disclosure of any private conversations or images without the consent of all parties involved. This includes in-person conversations, telephone calls, and electronic communications. The state's laws also specifically address the use of hidden cameras, which are prohibited in private places without the consent of the individuals being recorded.

Michigan's eavesdropping law, Mich. Comp. Laws § 750.539c, makes it a criminal offense to use any device to record, obtain, or share oral or electronic communications without the consent of all contributing parties. This is often referred to as a "two-party consent" law, meaning that all parties involved in a conversation must agree to be recorded. However, there is some disagreement among courts in Michigan about whether this law applies to participants in the conversation. While some courts have interpreted the law to mean that all parties must consent, including participants, others have ruled that participants in a private conversation can record without violating the statute because the term "eavesdrop" refers only to the act of overhearing or recording the conversations of others. As of the last update on May 2020, the Michigan Supreme Court, which has the final say on the matter, has not yet ruled on this issue.

Michigan's hidden camera law, Mich. Comp. Laws § 750.539d, prohibits the installation or use of any device for observing, recording, transmitting, photographing, or eavesdropping on sounds or events in a private place without the consent of the individuals entitled to privacy in that place. The law defines a "private place" as a location where an individual can reasonably expect to be safe from intrusion or surveillance, excluding places accessible to the public or a substantial group of the public. Violating this law can result in both civil and criminal penalties, including fines of up to $2,000 and imprisonment of up to two years.

In addition, it is illegal in Michigan to disclose or distribute recordings, photographs, or videos that were obtained illegally. This includes sharing information that was intercepted through eavesdropping or video capture without consent. Violating this law can result in felony charges, with fines of up to $5,000 and imprisonment of up to five years.

While Michigan's laws prohibit the recording of private conversations and the use of hidden cameras without consent, there are some exceptions. For example, the installation of a security surveillance system in a residence is legal if it is done at the request of the owner or primary occupant and not for lewd purposes. Additionally, recording government officials engaged in their duties in public places is generally permitted under the First Amendment.

Frequently asked questions