Toby's Ankle Monitor: A Season 1 Mystery

In Season 1 of Pretty Little Liars, Toby Cavanaugh is seen wearing an ankle monitor as he is under house arrest. He is suspected of murdering Alison DiLaurentis and is released from jail due to insufficient evidence. However, he has to wear an ankle monitor to keep him close to his step-sister, Jenna, whom he had a sexual relationship with. The audience later learns that Toby was forced to take the fall for The Jenna Thing by Alison, who knew about his relationship with Jenna.

Toby was wearing an ankle monitor because he was on house arrest

The ankle monitor played a significant role in the plot, as it symbolised Toby's restricted freedom and the suspicion surrounding him. The other characters, especially Emily and Spencer, noticed the monitor and questioned Toby about it. The device served as a constant reminder of his precarious situation and the possibility that he could be convicted of a crime he didn't commit.

It's worth noting that there are some inconsistencies in the show regarding Toby's ankle monitor. In certain scenes, he is seen without the monitor, even though he should be wearing it due to the terms of his house arrest. This has led to fan theories and speculation about the purpose and authenticity of the monitor. Some viewers have suggested that Toby may have been faking the ankle monitor at times to create an alibi for himself or to avoid suspicion of his involvement in certain incidents.

Toby's house arrest and ankle monitor contributed to the overall suspense and intrigue of the show, as it placed him in a vulnerable position and raised questions about his true nature and involvement in the events unfolding in Rosewood.

The ankle monitor was a clever alibi

In the first season of Pretty Little Liars, Toby Cavanaugh is seen wearing an ankle monitor as part of his house arrest. This was due to him being wanted for the murder of Alison DiLaurentis. However, upon rewatching the season, fans have pointed out that the timeline of Toby's house arrest and the usage of his ankle monitor don't quite add up.

In one episode, Toby is seen tampering with something around his ankle using a screwdriver, and he tells Emily that he can barely leave his porch. However, in the same episode, Spencer sees him in the street, and later, he is seen driving to the hospital without his ankle monitor. In another episode, Spencer sees him going into city hall without the monitor, and he is escorted by police to collect books from his locker at school.

These inconsistencies have led fans to speculate that Toby was faking the ankle monitor at first to have a solid alibi for not being involved in any "-A type antics". This would explain how he could have been at the dance-a-thon, where someone wearing a similar outfit to Toby collects a jacket from Ella. Later in the season, Toby is seen with a real ankle monitor, which looks different from the previous one. This could be interpreted as a clever alibi, allowing him to be in two places at once and throwing suspicion off himself.

The ankle monitor, combined with his house arrest, served as a convenient excuse for Toby's whereabouts and activities. It provided him with a plausible reason to be at home or unable to leave his porch, while also giving him the freedom to move around unnoticed when needed. This dual nature of the ankle monitor, real and fake, adds an intriguing layer to Toby's character and his potential involvement in the show's mysteries.

Toby was faking the ankle monitor at first

In Season 1 of Pretty Little Liars, Toby Cavanaugh is seen wearing an ankle monitor while on house arrest. However, there are several inconsistencies in the narrative that suggest he may have been faking the ankle monitor at first.

Firstly, there are discrepancies in the timing of Toby's house arrest. In one episode, Spencer sees him in the street going into city hall, and he is not wearing an ankle monitor. Later, in the same clothes, she sees him in the street again, indicating that he is not under house arrest at that time.

Secondly, the device around Toby's ankle appears to change. When Emily sees him on his porch, he is seen tampering with something around his ankle using a screwdriver, and it looks more like a watch than an ankle monitor. However, when Spencer visits him later, he shows her an ankle monitor, and it looks different from the one he had on his porch.

These inconsistencies led fans to speculate that Toby was faking the ankle monitor initially to create an alibi for himself and throw off any suspicions of his involvement in "A" type activities. This theory is further supported by the fact that Toby is seen wearing a leather jacket similar to that of "A" in the ending scenes of Season 1, indicating his possible involvement in the A-team.

While the exact reasons for Toby's ankle monitor may be unclear, these observations suggest that he may have been manipulating his house arrest situation to his advantage, adding an intriguing layer to his character and his potential involvement in the show's mysteries.

The ankle monitor doesn't add up upon rewatching

Upon rewatching Pretty Little Liars Season 1, there are some inconsistencies regarding Toby's ankle monitor and house arrest. Toby Cavanaugh, who was arrested for the murder of Alison DiLaurentis, is seen wearing an ankle monitor as part of his house arrest conditions. However, there are several instances where his whereabouts and the presence of the ankle monitor don't seem to align.

For example, Spencer sees Toby in the street going into city hall without the ankle monitor, indicating that he is out on bail. In another instance, Emily sees him on his porch, appearing to tamper with something around his ankle, which looks more like a watch than an ankle monitor. Later, Emily sees Toby sitting on his stoop wearing the ankle monitor and heads over to talk to him.

There is also an episode where Spencer is out jogging and sees Toby in the street. He runs into an alley and crouches beside a dumpster, indicating that he is not confined to his house as he should be if he is under house arrest. Additionally, the ankle monitor that Toby shows Spencer when she comes to tutor him looks different from the one he had on when Emily saw him on his porch.

These inconsistencies suggest that there may be more to Toby's house arrest and ankle monitor than meets the eye. It is possible that Toby was faking the ankle monitor at certain times or that there were issues with continuity and prop management in the show.

Overall, the presence of Toby's ankle monitor and the conditions of his house arrest don't seem to add up upon rewatching the season, leaving room for speculation and fan theories.

Toby was wearing a different ankle monitor later

In Season 1 of Pretty Little Liars, Toby Cavanaugh is seen wearing an ankle monitor as a result of being on house arrest. This house arrest is due to his involvement in "The Jenna Thing," where he took the fall for his stepsister, Jenna, after being blackmailed by Alison DiLaurentis, who knew about his sexual relationship with Jenna.

However, there are inconsistencies with Toby's ankle monitor throughout the season. In one instance, Spencer sees him in the street going into city hall without the monitor, and in another, Emily sees him tampering with something around his ankle that looks more like a watch than a monitor. Later, Spencer sees him running freely in the street and hiding in an alley, indicating he is not confined to his house.

The most notable discrepancy occurs when Spencer goes to tutor Toby. He gestures to an ankle monitor, and this one looks different from the one he had previously when he was on the porch. This suggests that Toby may have been faking the ankle monitor initially to throw off suspicion and create an alibi for himself.

The changes in Toby's ankle monitor throughout Season 1 of Pretty Little Liars indicate inconsistencies in the narrative and raise questions about the authenticity of his house arrest.

Frequently asked questions