Camera Tickets: Legal In Miami-Dade County?

The use of red light cameras in Miami-Dade County, Florida, has been a contentious issue, with legal challenges and varying opinions on their effectiveness and legality. While some argue that these cameras improve traffic safety, critics maintain that they amount to a money grab by local governments and camera companies. In 2015, Judge Leifman ruled that the way red light camera tickets were issued in Miami-Dade County was illegal due to the unfettered discretion given to the private vendor in screening images and sending potential violations to the police. However, this ruling was not final, and the case went to the Court of Appeals. As of 2024, speed cameras are expected to be installed outside schools in Miami-Dade County, with automated $100 citations issued to those caught speeding.

Red light camera tickets ruled illegal in Miami-Dade County

On September 25, 2015, Judge Leifman ruled that the way red light camera tickets were issued in Miami-Dade County was illegal. The ruling stated that a private vendor unlawfully screened the images and sent the ones that it deemed to be violations to the police to issue tickets. The Fourth District Court deemed it unlawful for the private vendor to have such "unfettered discretion".

The ruling states that all cities in the county should have the same rules when it comes to enforcing red light camera violations. However, this ruling is not final and does not apply to the entire state. Only a decision by the Florida Supreme Court can affect red light camera tickets state-wide.

Despite the ruling, the City of Miami and other agencies have fixed the issue and are issuing violations correctly. If you receive a ticket, you should not ignore it. Ignoring a red light ticket can result in late fees and license suspension.

Red light camera tickets can result in fines of $158

Red light camera tickets in Miami-Dade County can be issued when a vehicle enters an intersection after the light has turned red. A camera captures a photo of the car and its license plate, and an officer reviews the photo to verify that the vehicle has run a red light. The ticket is then mailed to the registered owner of the vehicle.

In Miami-Dade County, red light camera tickets can result in fines of $158. If the ticket is not paid, it becomes a citation for $277, which must be paid or contested in court. If an attorney is hired, their fee will need to be paid in addition to the fine if the judge rules that the ticket is legitimate.

It is important to note that ignoring a red light ticket can result in late fees and license suspension. Additionally, an unpaid ticket can be sent to a collection agency, affecting the individual's credit. Therefore, it is advisable to address and resolve any red light camera tickets received.

Ignoring a red light ticket can lead to late fees and license suspension

In Miami-Dade County, ignoring a red light ticket can lead to several consequences, including late fees and license suspension. It is important to note that even if some cities in the county are not enforcing red light cameras, ignoring a ticket can result in additional penalties.

If you choose not to pay the initial violation notice, it will typically increase in amount, and you will either have to pay the higher fine or contest it in court. In Miami-Dade County, the violation notice is $158, and if ignored, it becomes a citation for $277. Additionally, if you decide to hire an attorney to fight the ticket, you will likely have to pay their fee, which can be around $85, on top of the fine if the judge rules that the ticket is legitimate.

Failing to address a red light ticket can also lead to license suspension. In the past, issues with the process of issuing tickets and suspending licenses have been identified in Miami-Dade County. While the specific procedures have since been changed, it is important to take red light tickets seriously to avoid any negative consequences related to your driving privileges.

Moreover, an outstanding red light ticket can go to a collection agency, which can negatively impact your credit score and report. This can affect your ability to secure loans, rent an apartment, or obtain certain types of employment that require a credit check.

To avoid these potential consequences, it is advisable to address any red light tickets you receive promptly and take the necessary steps to resolve them. While you may choose to pay the fine, consulting with a traffic ticket attorney can help you understand your options and guide you through the process.

Red light cameras are allowed in school zones in Miami-Dade County

Red light cameras are currently allowed in school zones in Miami-Dade County, Florida. However, this hasn't always been the case, and there has been a long-running dispute about their use.

In 2016, Miami-Dade County banned red light cameras in unincorporated areas. Then, in 2018, a County Court Judge ruled that all cities in the county should have the same rules when it comes to enforcing red light camera violations. This ruling was not final and, as of 2024, red light cameras are still in use in Miami-Dade County.

In 2023, a proposal sponsored by Commissioner Anthony Rodriguez to allow speed enforcement cameras into the unincorporated areas was put forward. This proposal was given preliminary approval by the county commission in September 2023 and may be finalised by the end of the year. The new law would allow local governments to set up cameras to enforce speed limits in school zones, monitoring drivers' speed limits on school days during school hours.

The use of red light cameras in Miami-Dade County has been controversial. In 2015, Judge Leifman ruled that the way red light camera tickets were issued in the county was illegal, as a private vendor unlawfully screened images and sent those they deemed to be violations to the police to issue tickets. This gave the private vendor "unfettered discretion" in deciding which images to send to the police.

Despite this, red light cameras are currently allowed in school zones in Miami-Dade County, with the safety of school children being cited as the main reason for their implementation.

Red light camera tickets are not uniform across Florida

The cost of red light camera tickets is also not uniform across Florida. While in Miami-Dade County, the violation notice is $158, in Hillsborough County, the penalty is the same amount, but if not paid, it becomes a $277 citation. In contrast, in Orlando, the fine for a red light camera ticket is $262.

The process of issuing red light camera tickets also varies across Florida. In Miami-Dade County, a private vendor screens images and sends those they believe to be violations to the police. In contrast, in Hillsborough County, law enforcement officials review the evidence and decide whether to issue a ticket.

The use of red light cameras in Florida has been controversial. Lawmakers have questioned the fairness of the law, and there have been attempts to repeal it. Critics argue that red light cameras do not punish "bad" driving and instead impose expensive fines for minor infractions. On the other hand, supporters of red light cameras claim that they improve road safety, particularly in school zones.

Frequently asked questions