Frankfurt Brothels: Are They Under Surveillance?

Frankfurt, Germany's fourth-largest city, has long been a hub for prostitution and drugs, with the industry thriving alongside its trade fairs. The city takes a pragmatic and compassionate harm reduction approach to these issues. Prostitution was legalised in 2002, and sex workers are entitled to healthcare and pay taxes on their income. Frankfurt's red-light district, known as Bahnhofsviertel, is home to numerous brothels, including the largest brothel in Germany, Crazy Sexy, with 180 rooms. While prostitution is legal and regulated, concerns about human trafficking and forced prostitution persist, and the ethics of visiting brothels are debated.

Frankfurt's red-light district

During World War II, the Bahnhofsviertel district suffered only minor damage from bombs, and many of its hotels were used by US occupation forces to accommodate military personnel. The socioeconomic disparity between the German population and the relatively wealthy US soldiers contributed to the emergence of the red-light district in this area.

Today, Frankfurt's red-light district is known for its variety of brothels, ranging from small to large establishments, some with over 3000 square metres of space. The core of the district is formed by Elbestrasse, Moselstrasse, and Taunusstrasse, with the latter being particularly associated with the red-light activities.

One notable brothel in the district is Crazy Sexy, located at 51 Elbestrasse. With 180 rooms, it is the largest brothel in Germany. The establishment caters to a range of sexual preferences and offers services such as full-body massages and live sex shows. Another well-known brothel is Taunusstrasse 27, one of the oldest spots for sex in the district, featuring international prostitutes and a variety of sexual services.

While prostitution is legal in Germany, there are regulations in place to protect sex workers and their clients. For example, since December 2018, clubs have been required to phase out unprotected sex advertisements, and prostitutes must register with relevant municipal councils and maintain updated health licences.

Prostitution legalisation

Prostitution laws vary significantly across the world, with some countries adopting a prohibitionist approach, where prostitution is illegal and criminalized, while others, like Germany, have legalized and regulated the industry. The topic of prostitution legalization is highly nuanced, and perspectives on it are often influenced by one's views on morality, ethics, and human rights.

Arguments for Legalization

Proponents of legalizing prostitution argue that it would bring the industry out of the shadows, reducing crime and empowering sex workers to report abuse without fear of criminalization or police harassment. This view is supported by organizations such as Amnesty International, which advocates for the decriminalization of sex work to protect the rights of sex workers. Additionally, legalization could improve public health by facilitating access to healthcare services and mandatory health checks for sex workers. It could also increase tax revenue for governments and help people escape poverty.

Another argument for legalization is that it respects the freedom of consenting adults to make their own choices. This perspective is supported by civil liberties organizations like the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), which asserts that consenting adults should not be jailed for private sexual conduct. Furthermore, the criminalization of sex work disproportionately impacts women, LGBTQ+ individuals, young people, and people of color, who are overrepresented in the sex industry.

From an economic standpoint, some argue that legalizing prostitution would reduce the black market for such services, which is often controlled by criminal underworlds. By regulating and taxing the industry, governments can benefit financially, as seen in Germany, where prostitution is taxed and contributes to the country's economy.

Arguments Against Legalization

Opponents of legalizing prostitution believe that it would lead to negative societal consequences, including an increase in sexually transmitted diseases, global human trafficking, and violent crimes such as rape and homicide. They view prostitution as inherently immoral and commercially exploitative, reinforcing the objectification of women and empowering criminal elements.

Some feminist organizations oppose prostitution, considering it a form of male dominance and exploitation of women. They argue that prostitution results from a patriarchal social order and reinforces stereotypical views of women as sex objects. Additionally, opponents argue that legalization would increase the demand for prostitution, leading to a rise in human trafficking and underage prostitution to meet that demand.

Another concern is that legalization would legitimize and normalize the act of buying sex, sending a message that women and girls are commodities to be bought and sold. This perspective is shared by former U.S. President Jimmy Carter, who believes that legalization would codify a form of violence against women and normalize the entitlement of men to access women's bodies.

Health and safety laws

Prostitution in Frankfurt, Germany, has been legal since 2002. German sex workers are entitled to healthcare and pay taxes on their income. In Frankfurt, prostitution is contained and controlled within what is known as a "tolerance area".

In terms of health and safety laws, prostitution in Frankfurt is regulated to ensure the safety of both sex workers and clients. Sex workers are required to rent their rooms, which helps to ensure that they are working independently and not being controlled by pimps. This also means that they can run their own businesses and set their own rules.

During the COVID-19 pandemic, brothels in Frankfurt were ordered to close temporarily to prevent the spread of the virus. This demonstrates that the city takes health and safety concerns seriously and is willing to take proactive measures to protect public health.

It is important to note that there are still risks associated with visiting brothels, including the possibility of sexually transmitted infections. It is recommended to be respectful, practice good hygiene, and use protection to minimize these risks.

Overall, Frankfurt's regulated prostitution environment aims to provide a safe space for sex workers and clients, while also addressing broader health and safety concerns.

Foreign sex workers

Germany has seen a large influx of foreign sex workers, mostly from Eastern Europe, since the legalisation of prostitution in the country. In Frankfurt, the commercial and financial hub of Germany, prostitution is legal and widespread. The city's red-light district is home to a variety of sex workers from all over the world, including Romania, Moldova, Spain, Germany, Latin America, and even China.

Eastern European women, particularly from Bulgaria and Romania, have been flooding the German sex market since the eastward expansion of the EU in 2007. In Frankfurt's brothels, about 90% of women are from Eastern Europe, and they often come from slum conditions, with little to no education, and a history of violence. They are vulnerable to exploitation by pimps and brothel owners, who take a significant cut of their already meagre income.

The competition from foreign sex workers has driven down prices, and local sex workers like Anna, a 25-year veteran of the industry, have seen their earnings and working conditions deteriorate. Foreign sex workers often charge lower rates, with street hookers, for example, offering their services for as little as 15 euros.

Some foreign sex workers, like Dana, a former head salesclerk in a Bulgarian supermarket, have chosen the profession as a way to earn more money. She earns 25 euros for 15 minutes of work, but she faces dangers like sexually transmitted diseases, aggressive clients, and other pimps.

Another challenge faced by foreign sex workers is the language barrier. Many of the Eastern European women cannot speak German, which makes it difficult for them to understand their rights and access support services. This isolation makes them more vulnerable to exploitation and trafficking.

While prostitution is legal in Germany, the industry is largely unregulated. There have been recent efforts to implement new laws to protect sex workers, such as mandatory health checks and registration requirements. However, these measures are controversial, with some sex workers concerned about discrimination, forced outing, and potential harassment from clients if their information ends up in the wrong hands.

The foreign sex workers in Frankfurt's red-light district face a range of challenges, from low pay and unsafe working conditions to exploitation and trafficking. While the legalisation of prostitution was intended to empower sex workers, it has instead created an environment where they are vulnerable to abuse and struggle to earn a living.

The city's pragmatic approach

Frankfurt, Germany's fourth-largest city, has long been a trade hub, and prostitution has historically accompanied this trade. The city has adopted a pragmatic approach to the issue, legalising prostitution in 2002 and implementing harm reduction strategies. This approach recognises that prostitution is a significant industry, with an estimated €14 billion in annual declared income.

Frankfurt's pragmatic approach to prostitution is evident in its decision to contain and control the industry within a designated "tolerance area". This area, known as the Bahnhofsviertel or "train station quarter", is part of the city's dense inner-city districts. It is well-connected to public transportation and features high-rise brothels, or "eros towers". The city's pragmatic approach allows for the management of prostitution in a concentrated area, recognising the impracticality of outlawing the industry with the constant influx of businessmen and tourists.

The brothels in the red-light district vary in size, with some establishments boasting over 3000 square metres of space. The largest brothel in Germany, Crazy Sexy, is located in Frankfurt and features 180 rooms. The sex workers in these brothels are from diverse backgrounds, with most coming from Eastern Europe, Latin America, and Asia, while only about 2% are German.

In addition to managing prostitution, Frankfurt has also addressed the issue of drug use with a pragmatic harm reduction strategy. The city offers "pump rooms" or "drug consumption rooms" where hard drug users can inject in a safe and hygienic environment with medical help nearby. This approach has led to a significant reduction in overdose deaths, and locals consider the program a success.

Overall, Frankfurt's pragmatic approach to prostitution and drug use involves legalisation, harm reduction, and containment within designated areas. This strategy aims to balance the realities of these industries with the goal of minimising potential negative impacts.

Frequently asked questions