Are Toledo's Camera-Issued Speeding Tickets Legally Valid?

Speeding tickets in Toledo, Ohio, are a contentious issue. While some residents complain about the lack of police enforcement of speed limits, others question the validity of tickets obtained through speed cameras. According to a 2024 Reddit post, speed camera violations are no longer considered valid debts that can be reported to credit agencies due to a 2016 court case. However, there are conflicting reports of people receiving collection letters and threats to their credit scores if they don't pay. The same post also mentions that the City of Toledo has tried to pursue civil judgments for unpaid camera-issued tickets, but these attempts seem rare and can be contested in court. Speeding tickets issued by police officers under the Toledo Municipal Code or the Ohio Revised Code are a different matter and can result in fines, points on one's license, and even license suspension or felony charges in extreme cases.

Speeding tickets from cameras are civil violations

Speeding tickets from cameras are generally considered civil violations or civil penalties, and are treated differently from traditional speeding tickets. These tickets are typically issued by mail to the owner of the vehicle, and not the driver, and are often seen as a way for municipalities to generate revenue. While they can result in financial penalties, they usually do not carry the same consequences as regular speeding tickets, such as license suspensions or increases in insurance premiums.

In the state of Ohio, for example, traffic camera tickets are enforceable and failure to respond or appear in court can lead to negative consequences such as license suspension and increased insurance premiums. However, these tickets are not treated as regular speeding tickets and are often considered civil violations. According to Section 4511.098 of the Ohio Revised Code, recipients of camera speeding tickets have the option to pay the civil violation or contest it.

The validity and enforceability of camera speeding tickets can vary depending on the specific location and applicable laws. In some places, these tickets may not have any legal weight, while in others they may result in financial penalties or other consequences. It is important for individuals to understand the laws and regulations in their specific jurisdiction to make informed decisions about how to handle camera speeding tickets.

In Toledo, Ohio, there have been reports of individuals receiving camera speeding tickets and being threatened with collections agencies if they do not pay. However, it is important to note that these tickets are not considered valid debts that can be reported to credit agencies. Individuals have the right to ask the collection agency to prove that the debt is owed, and in many cases, they are unable to do so. While there have been instances of municipalities attempting to file civil judgments against registered vehicle owners, this does not appear to be a common occurrence in Ohio.

Tickets are not valid debts

Speeding tickets issued by camera in Toledo, Ohio, are not considered valid debts. This is because they are civil violations and are not contractual agreements. These tickets hold little to no value and do not have any serious repercussions.

No Serious Repercussions

If you receive a speeding ticket by camera, you don't have to worry about losing your license or having your registration suspended. While the ticket can be sent to 'collections', it cannot be reported to credit bureaus and will not affect your credit score.

No Proof of Debt

Collection agencies are unable to prove that you owe the debt. If you ask them to prove it, they will be unable to, and they will stop contacting you after the 30-day limit. The only thing a municipality could do is file an official civil judgment against the registered owner, but this is rare and typically requires a fee.

Budget Cuts as a Deterrent

The state of Ohio has ruled that they can discount a municipality's budget by the amount generated through speed traffic violations. This has led to several municipalities, including Newburgh Heights, halting their traffic camera programs.

Fighting Civil Judgments

In some cases, people have successfully fought civil judgments on these tickets. For example, one person from Toledo shared their experience online, stating that they showed up to court and got their case dismissed.

While it is important to follow traffic laws and drive safely, these camera-issued speeding tickets are not something to worry about from a debt perspective. They are not valid debts, and there are no serious consequences for not paying them.

Tickets cannot affect driving licenses

In Toledo, Ohio, speed camera violations are considered civil violations and are no longer considered valid debts that can be reported to credit agencies. This is because the recipient of the ticket has not entered into a contractual agreement, and so these tickets are not worth the paper they are written on.

Recipients of these tickets cannot lose their licenses or have their registrations suspended. Although the tickets can be sent to 'collections', they cannot be reported to credit bureaus. It is possible to ask the collection agency to prove that the recipient owes the debt, which they cannot, and they will stop contacting the recipient after the 30-day limit.

The only thing a municipality could do is file an official civil judgment against the registered owner, which typically requires a fee and they would have to serve the recipient in person or via certified mail. This has not been heard of happening in Ohio.

In the case of a ticket being issued by a police officer, there is a possibility of losing your license. If you show up to court without a lawyer, you will probably lose your license. However, in the case of a speeding camera ticket, there is no way to prove who was driving, so they cannot put points against your license.

Municipalities can file an official civil judgement

In Toledo, Ohio, there have been questions raised about the validity of speeding tickets, particularly those issued by camera. Speeding in residential areas is a problem the city is working to address, and the Toledo City Council has tried to tackle the issue by increasing fines for speeding.

While speeding tickets are generally valid, there are some nuances to be aware of when it comes to tickets issued by camera. According to a Reddit post, speed camera violations are considered civil violations, and while municipalities can file an official civil judgment, this is rarely done in Ohio. The post also mentions a case where someone received a citation from the City of Toledo through civil court, but the case was dismissed.

Here's a more detailed look at the process and implications:

Civil Traffic Tickets vs. Criminal Traffic Tickets

Civil traffic tickets are given when a motorist or pedestrian is believed to have violated a civil traffic law, such as speeding, running a red light, or making an illegal turn. These tickets are typically classified as either moving violations or non-moving violations, depending on whether the car was in motion at the time. Civil traffic tickets carry relatively less harsh penalties than criminal traffic tickets and provide more options for resolution. Motorists who receive a civil traffic ticket can choose to pay the fine, attend defensive driving school (if eligible), or show up to court on the arraignment date.

On the other hand, criminal traffic tickets allege that the motorist has committed a criminal traffic violation, such as driving without a valid license or vehicular manslaughter. Criminal traffic tickets are handled more severely and carry more serious consequences, including potential jail time, license suspension, and hefty fines. Those who receive a criminal traffic ticket must appear in district court on the arraignment date and can plead guilty, no contest, or not guilty.

Municipalities and Civil Judgments

In the context of speeding tickets, municipalities can take legal action by filing an official civil judgment. This typically involves starting civil proceedings against the registered owner of the vehicle. According to the Ohio Supreme Court rules, service of process must be made via certified mail. However, as mentioned in the Reddit post, it seems rare for this to occur in Ohio.

Implications for Credit Score and Debt Collection

The same Reddit post also highlights that speed camera violations are not considered valid debts that can be reported to credit agencies. This is because there is no contractual agreement in place. While these tickets can be sent to debt collection agencies, they cannot be reported to credit bureaus. Additionally, if requested, the collection agency must prove that the debt is owed, which is often challenging for them to do.

Strategies for Contesting Tickets

When it comes to contesting speeding tickets, there are a few strategies worth considering:

• Request Proof of Debt: As mentioned earlier, asking the collection agency to prove that the debt is owed can often lead to the case being dismissed, as they typically cannot provide sufficient evidence.
• Consult a Traffic Attorney: Retaining a skilled traffic attorney can help reduce the likelihood of a traffic conviction and minimize fines and insurance premiums. They can guide you through the complex ticket citation system and improve your chances of a favorable outcome.
• Understand the Differences Between Civil and Criminal Tickets: Knowing the distinction between civil and criminal traffic tickets is crucial. Civil tickets offer more options for resolution and carry less severe penalties, while criminal tickets involve more severe consequences and require appearances in district court.
• Consider the Jurisdiction: It's important to understand the specific laws and regulations of the jurisdiction where the ticket was issued. For example, in some states, speeding violations may be classified as civil infractions, while in other states, they may be considered criminal charges.

Tickets are sent to collections

If you receive a speeding ticket from a camera in Toledo, it is still a valid ticket and you are expected to pay it. However, if you don't pay it, the ticket can be sent to a collections agency.

If you don't pay a speeding ticket, it can be sent to a collections agency, and the amount you owe may increase due to late fees. However, this doesn't necessarily mean that your credit score will be affected. Speed camera violations are civil violations and are no longer considered valid debts that can be reported to credit agencies. This is because you never entered into a contractual agreement to pay the debt.

If a ticket does go to collections, you can ask the collection agency to prove that you owe the debt, which they cannot do. They will then have to stop contacting you after a 30-day limit. Additionally, you can dispute the debt with the credit bureaus, and it should be removed from your record.

It is important to note that while the collection agency cannot report the debt to the credit bureaus, failing to pay it may still negatively impact your credit score if the debt is sold to a collection agency. In this case, you would negotiate payment with the collection agency, not the original issuer of the ticket.

To avoid this situation, it is advisable to pay any speeding tickets you receive, even if they are from a camera.

Frequently asked questions